Case Note & Summary
The dispute involved petitioners who were cabin holders in Baroda for over 20 years, seeking similar benefits as those granted by the Apex Court to other hawkers. The petitioners approached the High Court of Gujarat after the Apex Court issued an order on May 2, 1986, which required certain hawkers to remove their hand-carts and cabins by December 31, 1986, while allowing them to make representations regarding their trading zones. The petitioners filed an undertaking similar to those in the Apex Court case and sought directions for the Municipal Corporation of Baroda to extend the same benefits to them. The court considered the totality of the facts and decided to direct the Corporation to assess whether the petitioners' cases were identical to those previously adjudicated. If found identical, the same benefits should be extended; otherwise, the Corporation was to provide a reasoned order. The court also ordered that interim relief would continue until the Corporation made its decision, and the petitioners were to submit individual representations within two months. The Corporation was required to decide on these representations within three months, with the interim relief remaining in force for an additional two months if the decision was against the petitioners. The rule was disposed of without costs.
Headnote
A) Writ Jurisdiction - Extension of Benefits - Petitioners sought extension of benefits granted by the Apex Court to similar cases - Constitution of India, 1950 - Court directed the Municipal Corporation to consider the petitioners' claims for benefits identical to those granted to others, ensuring a reasoned order if distinctions were found. Held that interim relief would continue until the Corporation's decision (Paras 2-3).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the petitioners are entitled to the same benefits as those granted by the Apex Court to other hawkers and cabin holders.
Final Decision
The court directed the Municipal Corporation to consider the petitioners' claims for benefits identical to those granted to others, ensuring a reasoned order if distinctions were found. Interim relief was ordered to continue until the Corporation's decision.
Law Points
- Writ jurisdiction
- Municipal law
- Interim relief
- Representation rights
- Judicial review



