Case Note & Summary
The case involved a dispute regarding the allotment of government accommodation to a retired government servant and his daughter. The petitioner, who had served in the Government Medical Service, was entitled to a quarter upon his retirement, which he occupied until his daughter, also a government employee, could be allotted a quarter. Despite his entitlement, the authorities failed to process the allotment for the daughter, leading to demands for economic rent from the petitioner after his retirement. The petitioner corresponded with various authorities seeking the allotment but faced delays and refusals based on his daughter's marital status. The court analyzed the relevant government resolutions and circulars that provided for out-of-turn allotment to relatives of retiring government employees. It concluded that the demand for economic rent was unjustified and that the authorities had acted in a high-handed manner. The court directed the immediate release of the petitioner's retirement dues, including his last pay and gratuity, and awarded interest on the delayed payments. The court emphasized the need for timely payment and set a deadline for the authorities to comply with the order.
Headnote
A) Administrative Law - Government Accommodation - Economic Rent Demand - Quashing of unjustified demand for economic rent - Gujarat Public Premises (Eviction of Unauthorised Occupants) Act, 1972 - The court found that the demand for economic rent from the petitioner was unjustified as he was entitled to occupy the quarter until his daughter's allotment was processed, which was delayed by the authorities. Held that the demand was quashed and the authorities were directed to release the retirement benefits (Paras 20-21).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the demand for economic rent from the petitioner after retirement was justified and whether the petitioner was entitled to the release of retirement benefits.
Final Decision
The court quashed the demand for economic rent and directed the release of the last pay, no due certificate, and all retirement benefits to the petitioner. The court also awarded interest on the delayed payments at the rate of 15% per annum and set a deadline for compliance.
Law Points
- Government accommodation
- Economic rent
- Retirement benefits
- Allotment of quarters
- Administrative discretion



