Case Note & Summary
The dispute arose from the suspension of a Police Sub-Inspector (PSI) following allegations of misconduct involving alcohol and assault against a constable. A preliminary inquiry conducted by the Chief Police Inspector (CPI) led to the decision to hold a departmental inquiry, resulting in the PSI's suspension. The PSI filed a petition seeking to challenge the suspension, which was initially stayed, allowing for a restoration of his position prior to suspension. The inquiry officer ultimately exonerated the PSI, and the disciplinary authority, the District Superintendent of Police (DSP), agreed with this finding. However, upon reviewing the inquiry results, the Deputy Inspector General (DIG) issued an order that set aside the original chargesheet and directed a fresh inquiry, which led to the current petition. The court analyzed the powers of the DIG under the Bombay Police Act, particularly Section 27A, which limits the DIG's authority to confirming, modifying, or reversing orders rather than initiating a new inquiry. The court found that the DIG had exceeded his authority by nullifying the previous proceedings and ordering a fresh inquiry. Consequently, the court quashed the DIG's order and the subsequent chargesheet issued against the PSI, ruling in favor of the petitioner. The petition was allowed, and the impugned order and chargesheet were set aside.
Headnote
A) Administrative Law - Powers of Disciplinary Authority - Exceeding Authority - Bombay Police Act, 1951, Section 27A - The DIG exceeded his authority by setting aside the original chargesheet and ordering a fresh inquiry instead of confirming, modifying, or reversing the order as permitted under the Act. The court held that the disciplinary authority, being the DSP, must conclude the inquiry and the DIG cannot assume such powers. (Paras 5-10)
Issue of Consideration
Whether the DIG exceeded his authority in setting aside the original chargesheet and ordering a fresh inquiry.
Final Decision
The court quashed the impugned order of the DIG and the chargesheet dated 13.2.1985, ruling that the DIG exceeded his authority under the Bombay Police Act.
Law Points
- Disciplinary authority
- departmental inquiry
- powers of DIG
- Bombay Police Act
- quashing of chargesheet


