Case Note & Summary
The dispute arose between Sales Tax Inspectors (Enforcement) and the Commissioner of Sales Tax, Gujarat State, regarding the legality of their transfer from the Enforcement branch to the Administration branch. The petitioners were transferred to the Enforcement branch on 1st July 1992 and were aggrieved by a subsequent transfer order made on 29th January 1993, which they claimed was arbitrary and discriminatory, especially since they had served more than the three-year limit set by a policy circular. The petitioners argued that other officers had been allowed to remain in the Enforcement branch for longer periods, which they claimed was unfair. The court noted that the petitioners had indeed served their term in the Enforcement branch and were liable to be transferred out. However, it also acknowledged that the petitioners were not allowed to resume duty from 3rd February 1993 until 28th July 1993 due to a stay order. The court directed that this period be treated as time spent on duty, entitling the petitioners to wages for that duration. The petition was allowed to this extent, and the interim relief was vacated, with parties bearing their own costs.
Headnote
A) Employment Law - Transfer of Employees - Entitlement to Wages - Not applicable - Petitioners were transferred from the Enforcement branch after serving more than the stipulated period as per policy. Court held that the period during which the petitioners were not allowed to resume duty should be treated as period spent on duty, thus entitling them to wages for that duration. (Paras Not mentioned).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the petitioners were entitled to wages for the period they were not permitted to resume duty due to the stay on their transfer order.
Final Decision
The court allowed the petitioners' claim for wages for the period from 3rd February 1993 to 28th July 1993, treating it as time spent on duty. The petition was allowed to this extent, and the interim relief was vacated.
Law Points
- Transfer of employees
- Policy decision
- Wages entitlement
- Interim orders



