Case Note & Summary
The dispute arose from a petition filed by the owners of land in Dholka, Ahmedabad District, challenging an order imposing a fine for not completing construction of an industrial unit within the stipulated time after obtaining non-agricultural (N.A.) permission. The petitioners had received N.A. permission on September 24, 1981, with conditions to start construction within six months and complete it within three years. Due to breaches of these conditions, a fine was imposed by the District Development Officer (D.D.O.) on July 3, 1986. The petitioners contested this fine, leading to a review by the Secretary of Revenue, who referred the matter back to the D.D.O. for reconsideration of the N.A. permission. The court analyzed whether the imposition of fine was justifiable given that the D.D.O. had extended the N.A. permission, effectively condoning the earlier breaches. The court held that since the extension of permission negated the basis for the fine, the imposition was inconsistent with the law. Consequently, the court allowed the petition, set aside the fine, and directed the D.D.O. to reconsider the application for N.A. permission without restrictions. The court emphasized that the D.D.O. should consider all aspects of the case in making a fresh decision. No costs were awarded.
Headnote
A) Administrative Law - Imposition of Fine - Justification of Fine Imposition - Bombay Land Revenue Code, 1948 - The court examined whether a fine could be imposed when the conditions of N.A. permission were extended, concluding that the imposition of fine was unjustified after the extension of permission, as the wrong was effectively condoned. Held that the order imposing the fine was inconsistent with the law and could not be maintained (Paras 4-6).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the imposition of fine was justified after the extension of N.A. permission.
Final Decision
The court allowed the petition, set aside the fine imposed by the D.D.O. and the order of the Secretary of Revenue, and directed the D.D.O. to reconsider the application for N.A. permission without restrictions.
Law Points
- Imposition of fine
- Non-agricultural permission
- Discretion of authority
- Cancellation of permission
- Reconsideration of application



