Case Note & Summary
The dispute arose from a challenge by the petitioner against orders issued by the Collector of Junagadh District regarding the use of land for non-agricultural purposes. The petitioner, Ishwardas Meghomal, contested the Collector's order dated 7th May 1985, which imposed a penalty for breach of conditions attached to the non-agricultural use of land owned by Shree Navjeevan Cooperative Housing Society. The society had received permission to use the land, but the petitioner, who purchased a portion of the land in 1979, failed to commence construction within the stipulated six months and also rented part of the land to a circus. The Collector's order mandated the recovery of 40 times the non-agricultural cess and required construction to commence within a year. The petitioner argued that liability for the penalty should only apply to the portion of land purchased. However, the court found that all purchasers of the land are bound by the original conditions of the sanad, and thus the penalty was validly imposed on the petitioner for the entire land. The court dismissed the petition, allowing the penalty to stand while permitting the petitioner to seek proportionate recovery from the predecessor. The petitioner was also ordered to pay costs, part of which was to be donated to a fund for natural calamities. The court vacated any interim relief previously granted and discharged the rule.
Headnote
A) Land Law - Non-Agricultural Use - Liability for Penalty - Bombay Land Revenue Code, 1879, Section 48-4 - The court held that the purchaser of a part of the land is equally bound by the conditions attached to the non-agricultural permission granted for the entire land, and thus liable for the penalty imposed for breach of those conditions. The penalty cannot be apportioned between the petitioner and the predecessor in title. Held that the imposition of penalty was justified (Paras 7-8).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the petitioner can be held liable for the entire penalty despite purchasing only a part of the land.
Final Decision
The court dismissed the Special Civil Application, affirming the Collector's order imposing a penalty for breach of conditions attached to the non-agricultural use of land. The petitioner was directed to pay costs and deposit a portion in specified funds.
Law Points
- Breach of conditions
- Non-agricultural use
- Penalty imposition
- Land Revenue Code compliance



