Case Note & Summary
The dispute arose from various Special Civil Applications filed by village-level Primary Cooperative Societies in Gujarat, seeking indemnification for crop damages during the drought year of 1985 under the Crop Insurance Scheme, 1985-86. The petitioners argued that they were entitled to damages based on loans advanced from January 1985 to November 1985, despite the scheme's cut-off dates being set from April 1, 1985, to September 30, 1985. The court examined the historical context of agricultural credit in India, highlighting the transition from exploitative money lending to cooperative credit systems. The petitioners claimed that the cut-off dates were arbitrary and did not align with the agricultural practices in Gujarat, where loans were typically disbursed from January. They argued that the General Insurance Corporation (GIC) had accepted premiums for these loans without objection, thus precluding them from denying claims later. The respondents, including the GIC and the Union of India, maintained that the scheme explicitly covered loans disbursed only from April 1, 1985, and that the cut-off dates were established during consultations and workshops involving all stakeholders. The court ultimately upheld the cut-off dates, ruling that the petitioners were not entitled to claims for loans disbursed outside the specified periods, thereby dismissing the applications.
Headnote
A) Insurance Law - Crop Insurance Coverage - Eligibility for Claims - Crop Insurance Scheme, 1985 - Petitioners contended that the cut-off dates for insurance claims were arbitrary and did not reflect the actual agricultural practices in Gujarat. The court held that the scheme's implementation was bound by the agreed cut-off dates, thus denying claims for loans disbursed outside the specified period (Paras 11-21).
Issue of Consideration
Whether petitioners are entitled to damages under the Crop Insurance Scheme for loans disbursed prior to 01.04.1985 and after 30.09.1985.
Final Decision
The court partly allowed the Special Civil Applications, directing the respondents to settle the insurance claims for the insured crops in respect of kharif 1985 considering the period of crop loan disbursements between April 01, 1985 to November 10, 1985 within a period of three months from the date of receipt of the writ.
Law Points
- Crop Insurance
- Agricultural Credit
- Insurance Claims
- Government Policy
- Cooperative Societies



