Case Note & Summary
The dispute arose from the forfeiture of a parcel of land granted to the petitioner for industrial purposes in 1956. The Assistant Collector of Palitana ordered the forfeiture on 27th February 1984 due to the petitioner's failure to commence any industrial activity on the land for over 25 years. The petitioner challenged this order, asserting that there was no condition requiring him to start an industry within a specific timeframe and that the exercise of revisional powers after such a long period was unjustified. The petitioner also claimed a breach of natural justice due to the non-supply of the Mamlatdar's report. The respondents contended that the land should not remain unproductive indefinitely. The court noted that the petitioner had indeed failed to utilize the land for its intended purpose and that the lack of a specific time limit for starting an industry did not absolve him of the obligation to use the land reasonably. The court held that the forfeiture was justified and that the exercise of revisional powers was permissible despite the time lapse, as the non-use constituted a continuous contravention of the grant conditions. The court also dismissed the argument regarding the non-supply of the report as it was raised too late. Ultimately, the court rejected both the writ petition and the miscellaneous civil application, discharging the rule with no order as to costs.
Headnote
A) Land Law - Forfeiture of Land - Justification for Forfeiture - Bombay Land Revenue Code, 1879, Section 211 - The petitioner failed to start any industrial activity on the granted land for over 25 years, leading to forfeiture by the Assistant Collector. The court held that land granted for specific purposes should not remain unproductive for extended periods, thus justifying the forfeiture (Paras 5-6). B) Administrative Law - Exercise of Revisional Powers - Timeliness of Action - Bombay Land Revenue Code, 1879, Section 211 - The court found that non-user of land constituted a continuous contravention of the grant, allowing for the exercise of revisional powers even after 25 years. The court emphasized that discretion under Article 226 is not to be exercised in favor of the petitioner under such circumstances (Paras 6-7). C) Natural Justice - Non-Supply of Report - Principles of Natural Justice - The court ruled that the argument regarding non-supply of the Mamlatdar's report was a new plea and could not be raised for the first time in the petition. Thus, it did not warrant interference (Paras 7-8).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the forfeiture of land for breach of grant conditions was justified and whether the exercise of revisional powers after 25 years was permissible.
Final Decision
The court dismissed the writ petition and the miscellaneous civil application, affirming the forfeiture of the land and rejecting the claims of the petitioner regarding breach of natural justice and the exercise of revisional powers.
Law Points
- Forfeiture of land
- breach of grant conditions
- exercise of revisional powers
- principles of natural justice
- discretionary remedy under Article 226



