Case Note & Summary
The case involved a petition filed by Rajnikant R. Sata seeking to quash an order from the Collector of Electricity Duty, Government of Gujarat, which reverted him from the position of Electricity Duty Inspector back to his original post as a clerk. Rajnikant was initially appointed as a clerk in 1972 and later selected as an Electricity Duty Inspector in 1981 after a selection process. His probation was extended, and he worked in that capacity until the reversion order was issued in 1985. The respondents contended that the selection committee was improperly constituted and that Rajnikant was not part of the correct establishment. The court noted that the respondents raised inconsistent arguments regarding the validity of the selection committee and failed to provide evidence of any procedural violations. The court emphasized that Rajnikant was a direct recruit and could not be reverted to a lower post without proper justification. Citing a Supreme Court precedent, the court quashed the reversion order, allowing Rajnikant to continue as Electricity Duty Inspector and ordered both parties to bear their own costs.
Headnote
A) Employment Law - Reversion of Direct Recruits - Direct recruits cannot be reverted to lower posts - Constitution of India, 1950 - The court held that a direct recruit cannot be reverted to a lower post, as established in precedent, and found the reversion order invalid due to lack of proper justification and procedure. Held that the petitioner should continue in his position as Electricity Duty Inspector (Paras 6-7).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the order reverting the petitioner to his original post as clerk was valid and lawful.
Final Decision
The court quashed the reversion order dated 29.1.1985 and allowed the petitioner to continue as Electricity Duty Inspector, with both parties bearing their own costs.
Law Points
- Direct recruitment
- Reversion
- Selection Committee validity
- Employment law
- Fundamental rights



